|Vehicle details:||DAF XF95|
|Author:||DAF & Pico|
The customer complained of an EBS braking fault which occurred intermittently. When the fault occurred then the EBS light would illuminate on the display and the EBS function would revert to conventional braking. This fault had been a problem for some time.
When the vehicle's electronic systems were interrogated the same faults were always apparent:
The driver also reported that the radio fuse would blow regularly and that the interior lights would dim momentarily.
The vehicle was subjected to a variety of electrical tests to try and determine if the wiring harness or ECUs were damaged. It was noted that the starter motor and alternator both functioned correctly and that the power supply to the components measured at 24V. Further detailed inspections of harnesses on the chassis and in the cab provided no lead as to the under-voltage and over-voltage situations occurring simultaneously on both ECUs.
The DAF UK technical department were requested to assist. During their diagnosis of the vehicle, the vehicle's ECUs were monitored with the PicoScope oscilloscope for power fluctuations. During a road test the oscilloscope picked up anomalies in voltage supply which occurred for just a few milliseconds.
The trace below identifies a momentary voltage and current spike detected at the power supply to cab and to the Engine ECU for a period of 60 ms, but essentially it was noted that this occurred when the vehicle started to pull away from a rough road lay-by
This unusual fluctuation led the diagnosing engineer to investigate further, particularly the vibration on the power supply waveform. The driver was asked to drive in a variety of load related situations and the technical engineer monitored the scope for anomalies. As the vehicle slowed down in top gear full throttle was applied causing the engine to labour creating symmetrical spikes on the current draw into the cab as shown below.
The x axis is divided by 20 ms divisions and the spikes are repeated at a regular frequency of circa 5 ms.
At this point no fault had yet occurred but it could clearly be seen that a symmetrical resonance was creating a power supply issue.
Further testing found that when the exhaust brake was applied with the service brake, then the following spikes were created. On this occasion the voltage to the engine ECU spiked in time to the current spike of the main cab supply.
The voltage to the engine ECU exceeded the set range of the oscilloscope and was in excess of 50 volts. The current draw into the cab momentarily exceeded 50 amps.
Whilst the vehicle was being inspected and this set of waveforms being captured in the workshop, it was noticed that at idle the interior lights of the cab started to pulsate slightly.
The below trace shown is for a period of one second only and it clearly shows the voltages to engine ECU and EBS ECU spiking in time with the interior lights pulsating..
It was determined that a main power supply anomaly feeding the cab was the cause. It was known that earlier investigations had ruled out the starter motor, alternator and the main harness to the cab. Therefore the battery cables were manipulated whilst the oscilloscope continued to record the voltage spikes in time with the dimming interior lights. When the battery bridge cable was disturbed the waveform settled to a linear output as would normally be expected.
Close inspection of the battery bridge cable found a cracked solder joint between the cable and the battery clamp.
The oscilloscope allowed for multiple channel monitoring and gave graphical depiction of the unfolding problem that could be detected and analysed. The clues from the symmetrical waveforms and the timing of the natural resonance from the engine led to the investigation concentrating on a poor main power supply connection. Systematic manipulation of each of the main battery cables whilst observing the PicoScope traces allowed for immediate response of the waveform once the problem area was disturbed.
Replacement of the battery bridge cable restored a guaranteed linear voltage supply to the vehicle.
July 02 2014
Very cool. I used a similar method to find a intermittent charging system problem on a 30 ft. Gillig Transit Bus.
June 30 2013
By ’ battery bridge cable ’ i presume this is what links the batteries to 24V the system ? I used to call it a link lead.
Now if this is the case then surely it must have had a starting/charging issue somewhere along the way too ??
What was the reason for DAF UK Technical to be called in ?
It just seems typical to me of a dealer (if i presume correctly that you are an agent for DAF ?)that if the fault isn’t found in a click of a finger via GFF not to spend any more time & pass it on or revert to ‘swoptronics’.
Anyway it’s nice to see an HGV case study & would like to see a few more, when i was HGV based & had a scope been mentioned i would thought it was what was on the top of a rifle (DMM in them days)
June 28 2013
Interesting challenge which would surely have gone on for longer without the use of the PicoScope.